AccueilManagement devices and the quest for performance in the public sector
International Journal of Public Sector Performance Management (IJPSPM)
Publié le mardi 16 décembre 2008 par Delphine Cavallo
Guest Editors :
- Salvatore Maugeri, Professor, Orleans University, France
- Jean-Luc Metzger, Associate Researcher, Laboratoire Interdisciplinaire pour la Sociologie Economique (CNAM-LISE), France
For several decades, and with renewed vigour since the late 1980s, public action has been called into question. All public institutions: the State, local governments, health organizations, state-run companies have been the object of two types of criticism. Economic inefficiency was jointly denounced with what was perceived as lack of democracy, transparency, equality, fairness and even security.
The rhetoric of « modernization » owes its origin to this two-fold criticism and was paralleled with two decades of successive reforms. These, however, were essentially aimed at economic inefficiency, thus leaving aside all other dimensions of public action. Among these initiatives, we can note the privatizations of state-run companies and public services, the introduction of quality management tools, the renovation of HRM techniques, performance related pay, balanced scorecards, and the conversion of citizens into “clients” and “shareholders”. Lately, state budgeting was also aligned with performance based logics. Symptomatically, the French government announced its decision of submitting its ministers to the assessment of private management consultants.
Derived from private management practice, a new vision of performance was vested by NPM (New Public Management) approaches into the public sector. It assumed the shape of management devices and remains at the core of most public reforms. The objective of this special issue is precisely to analyze public management reforms in the light of these management devices.
In the opinion of many authors, management devices are not value neutral. They are increasingly seen as a mixture of principles, techniques and managerial doctrines, promoted by a heteronymous cluster of experts, professional groups and influential agencies. Hence, according to some public management researcher the idea of their unrestricted transfer and universal applicability is increasingly losing ground.
Indeed, claiming that organization models and control techniques brought about by the management devices are universal, constitutes the first action of public managers conforming to a standardized conception of performance. In that respect, is the use of terms such as “modernization”, “rationality”, “performance”, not the first step to conceding to a managerialist ideology? However, differences in nature and in purpose (social, political, judicial, institutional, organizational…) are too obvious between public and business universes to blindfold the drawbacks of such a blend.
Management devices go beyond a simple translation of executives’ desire into action. They are action generators triggering unexpected dynamics and enacting ideologies for which “managerialism” is merely a façade. They request new perspectives of public management research in which stakeholders, their professional experiences and moral preoccupations, implementation techniques and user’s strategies should all be considered. The analysis of the design and implementation of the tools of public action is also a means of understanding the dynamics of change, and highlighting the interactions between technocratic and political action. To what extend can management tools confer the appearance of rationality to public policies and provide an escape lane from legitimate debates? Up to what point could a “deviant” appropriation of tools alienate the outcomes of the intended reform?
Our call for papers is aimed at two fields of inquiry:
- First, the papers should question the capacities of management devices to introduce performance ideologies into public action doctrines. What is the nature of innovation (technologies, organizational patterns, assumptions)? Who are its instigators and what are their aims? How does it change the interactions between different categories of public agents, and between civil servants and their publics? Does it produce conflicts between the general interest and economic performances? Can such a “better” management work against the inner purposes of public action?
- Secondly, wouldn’t it be possible or even desirable to imagine a new vision of public performance, one that would outclass market transpositions? Are there any other sources of inspiration? And could these new approaches gain acceptance? Could third sector experiences provide new paths of thinking?
In all these respects, it would be interesting to explain the success of managerialist approaches to performance. Does the century old glorification of the entrepreneurial firm explain this infatuation of the media, politicians and intellectuals? Or should it be attributed to the downhill image of the state and its traditional values? Is it possible that these trends prevent us from imagining alternatives and formulating criticisms? Does this create a vicious circle of societal perception from which we should escape?
All articles related to these issues in local or central governments, public services, and entities, or state owned companies would be greatly appreciated.
- Submission of full paper before: 1st May, 2009
- Notification of acceptance before: 1st July, 2009
- Submission of final and revised manuscripts: 1st September, 2009
Editors and Notes
You may send one copy in the form of an MS Word file attached to an e-mail (details in Author Guidelines) to the following:
- Salvatore Maugeri
- Jean-Luc Metzger
with a copy to:
- IEL Editorial Office
- Marcel Guenoun
- vendredi 01 mai 2009
- performance, public, devices, sociology of management
- Salvatore Maugeri
courriel : salvatore [dot] maugeri [at] univ-orleans [dot] fr
- Jean-Luc Metzger
courriel : jeanluc [dot] metzger [at] orange-ftgroup [dot] com
URLS de référence
Source de l'information
- Marcel Guenoun
courriel : marcel [dot] guenoun [at] univ-cezanne [dot] fr
Pour citer cette annonce
« Management devices and the quest for performance in the public sector », Appel à contribution, Calenda, Publié le mardi 16 décembre 2008, http://calenda.org/196188