HomeFreedom of Research Today

HomeFreedom of Research Today

Freedom of Research Today

La liberté de la recherche aujourd'hui

Conflicts, practices, prospects

Conflits, pratiques, perspectives

*  *  *

Published on Wednesday, November 08, 2017


In light of recent attacks against the freedom of research, we seek to reassess and reflect on the right to this freedom today, in a global context. Taking into account the punctual, tendential or structural nature of the attacks against this right, we focus on its current situation, its personal and collective practices as well as the networks and associations supporting it, and its political prospects. We adopt an encompassing, grounds-up and agonistic understanding of the freedom of research, which includes forms of journalistic, artistic and civic inquiry as well as academic research, situating it in a web of social, political and economic interrelations, and stressing the importance of understanding it as a contested right and a tool in conflict rather than simply an entitlement supposedly guaranteed by any “non-authoritarian” State.



A series of recent political events underline the urgency of interrogating the state of freedom of research today: repression of Turkish academics; violence against US researchers working on the “Arab spring”; death threats against academics working on the peace process in Colombia; seizure of the documents of French researchers working on the question of terrorism; conviction of Italian researchers for having participated in demonstrations against the TGV line in Val di Susa; dismissal of US researchers following Occupy Wall Street… The “defense of freedom of research” is, in these cases, clearly embedded in a broader social context: a context of political conflicts and social tensions where academic institutions and social struggles coincide. Moreover the “research” whose freedom is to be defended must be understood in a broad sense: as the freedom to investigate, to engage in the production of knowledge, to speak publicly, and to mobilize, not only for academics but also for journalists, trade unionists, artists, activists and citizens.

We thus consider the traditional notion of freedom of research to be insufficient in so far as it evokes primarily ideological oppositions and governmental repressions of freedom of expression. It understands the freedom of research as simply a constitutive part of our modern societies and interprets any attack against it as the sign of an authoritarian aberration. We propose to reflect rather on the critical, confrontational and political nature of the voices and inquiries of researchers, journalists, trade unionists, artists and activists. As such, this freedom is not a given whose continuity is to be ensured; it becomes an issue only in so far as it is exercised, connected to contention, opposition and conflict, to challenging the legitimacy of power structures and to demanding protection from prosecution. In its very core, the freedom of research is agonistic, and it engages democracy as to the capacity of its institutions and public spaces to stage political conflict, to foster and circulate critical inquiry and questioning, and to protect the citizens that exercise their freedom of research. 

The 16th to the 18th of November 2017, we organize an international forum in Paris featuring plenary sessions, parallel round-table discussions and documentaries, bringing together academics as well as other actors, in particular, journalists, unionists, associations and artists. Three objectives will structure our discussions. I) Understand and assess the state of the freedom of research today in a global context: the history of the right to the freedom of research, economic and political conditions and constraints, relations and tensions with the State as well as guarantees and protections, exercise and risks in current political conflicts, and the danger of current sclerotic dynamics due to vested and corporative interests. II) Share, explore and map personal and collective practices that both heavily depend on and invigorate the freedom of research – practices in relation to which this right is crucial –, as well as political, activist and solidarity-based efforts to uphold, support and protect it and the citizens exercising it. III) Outline and evaluate the political prospects of the freedom of research today, based on its difficulties and challenges in different local, national and geopolitical contexts, the networks and effective rights in place, the practices and experiences of different actors, and its political, economic and social horizons, in order to develop a normative and politically motivated notion of the freedom of research today.



Thursday 16.11.2017

09:30–10:00 Welcome and Registration

10:00–11:00 Introduction to the Forum

11:00–13:00 Plenary Session 1: The State of the Freedom of Research Today

Chair: Asli Telseren

  • Michel de Pracontal (Mediapart) 
  • Alain Prochiantz (president of the Executive Committee of PAUSE, Collège de France) 
  • Stephen Wordsworth (Executive Director of CARA, The Council for At-Risk Academics) 
  • Özlem Yüzak (journalist, Cumhuriyet)

13:00–14:30 Lunch

14:30–16:30 Parallel sessions

2a: Ethics, Politics, and Responsibility

Chair: François Reyssat

  • Aude Lapprand (Sciences citoyennes) 
  • Sylvain Laurens (EHESS) 
  • Alison Macrina (Library Freedom project)
  • Michel de Pracontal (Mediapart) 

2b: Research in/on Political Conflicts

Chair: Anders Fjeld

  • Tomislav Bogdan (University of Zagreb)
  • Maddalena Gretel Cammelli (Osservatorio per la libertà di ricerca sui fascismi di ieri e di oggi)
  • Dilnur Polat (INALCO)
  • Mansur Teyfuri (Université Paris 8)

2c: Freedom of Research and Ecology

Chair: Annika Raapke

  • Danièle Clavel (Cirad)
  • Fabrice Flipo (Université Paris Diderot)
  • Margaret Janz (DataRefuge)
  • Yoshiyuki Sato (University of Tsukuba) and Takumi Taguchi (University of Utsunomiya)

17:00–20:00 Film: "As I open my eyes", of Leyla Bouzid

Projection followed by a discussion with Leyla Bouzid

Friday 17.11.2017


Plenary Session 3: Articulating Research and Social Struggles

Chair: Anouk Colombani

  • Fulya Atacan
  • Christine Castejon (Étonnants travailleurs)
  • Norma Michi (Universidad Nacional de Luján)
  • Diego Paredes (Universidad de Buenos Aires)

11:00–13:00 Parallel Sessions

4a: Research in Political History and History Politics

Chair: Annika Raapke

  • David Adler (Ruhr-Universität Bochum)
  • Julian Hamann (Forum Internationale Wissenschaft, Bonn)
  • Jens Maeße (University of Gießen)

4b: Searching for funds and funding research

Chair: Brice Nocenti

  • Kolja Lindner (Université Paris VIII)
  • Christian Martinez-Perez (University of Reims Champagne Ardenne)
  • Leila Miñano (Youpress)

4c: Freedom of research and the State

Chair: Charlotte Dessaux

  • Gözde Aytemur (Université de Galatasaray)
  • Marwan Mohammed (Center Maurice Halbwachs)
  • Pinar Selek (Universite Nice Sophia Antipolis)

13:00–14:30 Lunch

14:30–16:30 Plenary Session 5: The politics of the freedom of research

Chair: Nathalie Montoya

  • Anna Biselli (netzpolitik.org)
  • José Lopez Mazz (Universidad de Montevideo)
  • Étienne Tassin (Université Paris Diderot)

17:00–19:00 Documentary: "Las manos en la tierra", of Virginia Martínez

Projection followed by a discussion with José Lopez Mazz, one of the protagonists in the documentary

20:00 Forum Dinner

Saturday 18.11.2017


Plenary Session 6: Which freedom of research to defend?

Chair: Anders Fjeld

  • Pascale Laborier (Université Paris Nanterre) and Sophie Wauquier (Université Paris 8)
  • Eric Marlière (Université de Lille)
  • Daniel Munier (Scholars at Risk)
  • Yotetsu Tonaki (Keio University, Tokyo)

11:00–13:00 Parallel Sessions

7a: Workshop: Methods of Resistance, Struggling for the Freedom of Research

Chair: Anders Fjeld and François Reyssat

  • Sarah Caunes (Université Paris 8)
  • Zeynep Kilvicim (Institute for Advanced Study Berlin)
  • Laura Lohéac (PAUSE)
  • Sarah Willcox (Scholars Rescue Fund)

7b: Producing/orienting research from struggles

Chair: Anouk Colombani

  • Sarah Brown and Inès Marie
  • Christian Mahieux and Théo Roumier (Les Utopiques, Worker Union journal)
  • Etienne Penissat (Sciences populaires Saint-Denis)

7c: Freedom of Research in Arts

Chair: Charlotte Dessaux

Form (rapper and founder of FICKO magazine)

Théâtre de l'opprimé

13:00–14:30 Lunch

14:30–16:00 Final discussion: Synthesis, feedback and future activities


  • La Halles aux farines 9-15, esplanade Pierre Vidal-Naquet
    Paris, France (75013)


  • Thursday, November 16, 2017
  • Friday, November 17, 2017
  • Saturday, November 18, 2017


  • Recherche, liberté, censure, surveillance, expression, protection, État, chercheurs, syndicat, citoyen, journalisme, associations, solidarité, Turquie


  • Anders Fjeld
    courriel : afjeld [at] gmail [dot] com

Reference Urls

Information source

  • Anders Fjeld
    courriel : afjeld [at] gmail [dot] com


CC0-1.0 This announcement is licensed under the terms of Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal.

To cite this announcement

« Freedom of Research Today », Conference, symposium, Calenda, Published on Wednesday, November 08, 2017, https://doi.org/10.58079/ysj

Archive this announcement

  • Google Agenda
  • iCal
Search OpenEdition Search

You will be redirected to OpenEdition Search