HomeJewish Theatre as an Object of Anthropological Study

HomeJewish Theatre as an Object of Anthropological Study

Jewish Theatre as an Object of Anthropological Study

Le théâtre juif : un objet anthropologique ?

*  *  *

Published on Tuesday, January 11, 2022 by Lucie Choupaut

Summary

This study day aims to apprehend Jewish theatre (in all its forms of expression, both linguistic and aesthetic) from an anthropological perspective. Taking as a starting point the Talmudic proscription of theater and circus performances (Jerusalem Talmud, Avoda Zara, 18b) and confronting it with primary sources which attest to the presence of the theatre among the Jews, we formulate several questions. How is it possible to approach theatre within Judaism? As an anthropological object working on the construction and affirmation of a form of Jewishness apprehended according to its relation to the theatre? In other words, can theatre be conceived as a medium of the Jewish subject? Can we consider Jewish theatre independently of its links with the Bible? In what forms? What about the historical and biblical topics that are found in most writers?

Announcement

Argument

Theatre emerged centuries ago as a form of cultural expression, in the West and in the East alike, in all of its aesthetic aspects. It is a constant presence in the so-called « Western » sphere, one that flourishes in spite of a legacy of mistrust (up to and including prohibitions) based on philosophical and theological considerations (see Plato, The Republic, Book III, 394 and Book X, 604-6; Saint Augustine, The Confessions, Book III, 2). This link between theatre and society – a mixture of hatred and fascination – gave birth to various areas of socio-anthropological thought. Erving Goffman’s The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life (1956), resorting to the notion of theatre, interpreted the very world of human social interactions as a form of scenic performance.

Among the Jews, theatre is conceived of in various and contradictory ways, although there is true that there are very few direct sources between the Antiquity and the Italian Renaissance. The denunciation of theatre in Judaism is a relatively late phenomenon, which is mentioned in the Jerusalem Talmud (Avoda Zarah 18b) discussing a baraita dating most likely from the beginning of the Christian era.

And yet, theatre is certainly present among the Jews from the Antiquity onward, notwithstanding the tension between the Talmudic proscription and the actual practice. In addition to the few mentions in Letter of Aristeas, Philo and in several inscriptions, we know of a Jewish playwright exiled in Alexandria who wrote, in Greek in 200 BCE, a play entitled Exagoge, only fragments of which survive. The text, known to be a tragedy, is based on the biblical story of Exodus.

Centuries later, the first play in Hebrew (A Comedy of Betrothal) was written in the Renaissance Italy by a Jewish intellectual living in Mantua, Leone de’ Sommi, as well as the first treatise on theatre staging (Four Dialogues on Scenic Representation). This latter text, written in Italian, is at once a polemic « dialogue » with Aristotle’s Poetics and a reconsideration of the origins of theatre (which origins, he considers, are biblical and cabbalistic). For Sommi, the question of the body takes precedence over the text of the play (as dramaturgy), proposing a new optic for a Jewish history of theatre, even more so given that his works are of biblical and Talmudic inspiration.

The Italian-Jewish influence will determine some of the further developments in Hebrew drama; the poetic conventions of the Italian language will likewise be a major factor in the evolution of the Hebrew metrics. A growing interest in translating literary works into Hebrew includes also writing and adapting dramatic works. An example of this kind of double influence can be seen with some Dutch writers, such as David Franco Mendes, whose adaptation of Athalie bears influence of Moshe Chaim Luzzatto, the French theatre and the Viennese oratorio.

In all these cases, the fundamental question remains the one of the attitudes towards the Hebrew language: can the holy tongue be used as a vehicle for secular literature? The question is sometimes implicit, other times raised by the writings that accompany theatre production (for example, Moshe Chaim Luzzatto’s Leshon Limmudim, on Hebrew stylistics).

Considering the concrete presence of these primary sources, as well as the authors that might be seen as founding figures, how are we to understand theatre from a Jewish vantage point? Is it an anthropological object, bringing together and affirming a kind of Jewishness understood through its relationship to the theatre? In other words, can theatre be understood as a medium for the Jewish subject? Is it (also) a subject of controversy, occasioning a rereading of Aristotle with the idea of Hebrew (and religious) origins of theatre? Is there a common thread uniting Jewish theatre aesthetics that can be discerned all the way from Ezekiel the Tragedian, considering subsequent developments (biblical adaptations, Purimspiel, Yiddish and Judeo-Spanish theatre, memory theatre, contemporary Israeli theatre, or Jewish theatre in languages other than Hebrew)? Can Jewish theatre be studied independently of its links to the Bible? In what ways, and what about the historical and biblical subjects we find with most authors?

Submission guidelines

The conference is aimed principally at PhD candidates from a range of disciplines whose academic interests revolve around the Jewish languages and theatre and/or anthropological dimensions of Performing Arts. Other proposals from individuals within the academic community or artists are also welcome.

Conference paper proposals of around 250 words (in English or French) are to be sent to the members of the organization committee (alexandru.bumbas@inalco.fr and anamarija.vargovic@inalco.fr) by February 20, 2022, 23:59 CET (Paris time).

Please make sure to add a brief bio-bibliographical profile. Candidates will be contacted by the end of March 2022. The languages accepted for the conference are English and French.

The conference will be held at INALCO (Paris) on June 28, 2022.

There is a possibility for the papers to be published in a special issue on the online artistic-academic platform IN VIVO ARTS.

Organized by

  • DOCTORAL SCHOOL 265 Langues, littératures et sociétés du monde, INALCO Paris
  • PLIDAM (Pluralité des Langues et des Identités : Didactique, Acquisition, Médiations), INALCO Paris
  • CERMOM (Centre de Recherches Moyen-Orient Méditerranée), INALCO Paris

Scientific committee

  • Frosa BOUCHEREAU-PEJOSKA – PR (PLIDAM),
  • Elisa CARANDINA – MCF (CERMOM)
  • Alessandro GUETTA – PR (CERMOM)
  • Zeljko JOVANOVIC – MCF (CERMOM)
  • Madalina VARTEJANU-JOUBERT – MCF/HDR (PLIDAM)

Organization committee

  • Alexandru BUMBAS, PhD in Theatre Studies (Sorbonne Nouvelle) and PhD candidate Jewish Studies (INALCO)
  • Anamarija VARGOVIC, PhD candidate in Jewish Studies, INALCO

Places

  • 65 rue Grands Moulins
    Paris, France (75)

Event format

Full on-site event


Date(s)

  • Sunday, February 20, 2022

Attached files

Keywords

  • théâtre, juif, anthropologie, écriture, culture juive

Contact(s)

  • Alexandru Bumbas
    courriel : alexandru [dot] bumbas [at] inalco [dot] fr

Reference Urls

Information source

  • Alexandru Bumbas
    courriel : alexandru [dot] bumbas [at] inalco [dot] fr

To cite this announcement

« Jewish Theatre as an Object of Anthropological Study », Call for papers, Calenda, Published on Tuesday, January 11, 2022, https://calenda.org/953305

Archive this announcement

  • Google Agenda
  • iCal
Search OpenEdition Search

You will be redirected to OpenEdition Search